The Menhaden
The look is almost totally monochrome, with a bit of hardwood and some carefully curated plant life serving as accents. Furnishings come from Restoration Hardware, and the bathrooms are lavish and modern, with walk-in showers and in some cases deep soaking tubs. And space is plentiful, both in-room and outside — there’s a charming rooftop deck, the highest point in town, and each floor has a galley stocked with drinks and snacks.
Meanwhile the ground floor is home to the most significant public space: the restaurant, Bunker Bar, and The General Store Café. For getting around, there’s a fleet of loaner bikes, as well as a Moke electric car. And perhaps most convenient of all — the hotel is just two blocks from the end of the Long Island Railroad.
Smaller hotels like The Menhaden fill up quickly. If you can’t find what you’re looking for, contact us and we can help.
Location
Guest Score & Reviews
No verified stays yet.
Our 20-point scale is based on post-stay ratings from verified MICHELIN Guide guests. This feedback is important, and plays a role in helping us decide whether or not a hotel should remain in our selection.
Rooms & Rates
Book direct on MICHELIN Guide and feel secure with our dedicated travel specialist team ready to assist. Best prices are guaranteed. Find a better rate? Let us know.